Emission Trading Scheme
  1. About
  2. MSR
  3. ETS after 2020
  4. Latest Articles
  5. Publications

About the EU's Emissions Trading Scheme

 

The EU’s Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS) is the world’s largest carbon market, covering more than 11,000 large scale industrial plants in the EU, as well as Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway. The EU ETS covers about 40% of the EU’s greenhouse gas emissions, including energy companies, steel and cement plants, as well as intra-EU flights.

The EU ETS sets a limit on the amount of greenhouse gas emissions that can be emitted. Companies covered by the EU ETS receive or buy pollution permits – called EU Allowances -- one EU allowance allows for one tonne of CO2 to be emitted. The cap becomes slightly more stringent every year so that total emissions decline over time to minus 21% in 2020 and to minus 43% in 2030 from 2005 levels.

The ETS aims to help the EU achieve its emissions goals more cost-effectively. Moreover, the EU ETS is supposed to catalyze investments in energy-efficiency and renewable technologies. However, the EU ETS has failed to drive such climate friendly investment and here is why:

If a company has spare permits it can keep them to cover its future needs or sell them to another company. Instead of buying allowances, companies can also buy much cheaper carbon offsets from the Clean Development Mechanism and Joint Implementation. This despite the fact that evidence shows that a majority of these offsets do not represent real emissions reductions. The use of these offsets together with a weak target and the economic recession have made the EU ETS ineffective.

A gigantic surplus of more than 2.1 billion spare pollution permits (EU allowances) has built up. This is more than all companies participating in the ETS are allowed to emit in one year. By 2020, the EU ETS surplus will have grown to between 2.6 and 4.5 billion allowances. As a result, the price for allowances has dropped so significantly that the EU ETS no longer facilitates the transition towards a renewable and energy efficient economy, and companies can delay or cancel investments in cleaner and more efficient production, risking a costly lock-in in carbon intensive infrastructure for years to come.

An overhaul of the EU ETS is urgently needed. Otherwise Europe risks a costly lock-in in fossil fuels for years to come:
• The road to EU ETS reform starts with the Market Stability Reserve (read more in the "MSR" section)
• ETS after 2020: The reforms we need to see (read more in the "ETS after 2020" section)

The low price of pollution permits has allowed coal use in Europe to remain stubbornly high. To reverse this trend and rapidly phase out coal, advocacy work against new coal plants and political lobbying for a range of policy measures that stop subsidizing coal and catalyze energy efficiency and renewable energy are needed. (link to coal section)

The EU ETS has long been hailed as the cornerstone of the EU’s efforts to tackle climate change. Failure to implement effective policy reforms will compromise the EU’s ability to be a global leader on climate issues and may diminish its influence in international climate negotiations leading to a new global climate agreement to be signed in Paris end of this year. 

 

Market Stability Reserve

The EU ETS has faced a severe price crash due to a very large oversupply of pollution permits, called EU allowances (see the "About" section).

The Market Stability Reserve (MSR) as proposed by the European Commission tries to address this supply and demand imbalance and create more price stability. Under the proposal, EU allowances would automatically be put into the MSR when there is a large oversupply of emission allowances and released back into the market when allowances are scarcer.

But the current proposal needs to be strengthened if the MSR catalyze investments in energy-efficiency and renewable technologies.

We propose the following improvements to the European Commission's Market Stability Reserve proposal:

1. Start the Market Stability Reserve in 2016
2. Prevent back-loaded and unused allowances from re-entering the market
3. Make adjustments stronger when the supply is large
4. Limit the surplus from being used as future rights to pollute

 


Read the CAN Europe position on the MSR here.

The Market Stability Reserve is an important first step towards the structural reforms needed to turn the EU ETS into an effective instrument that encourages clean investments and controls emissions (see the "ETS after 2020" section)

 

The following issues must be addressed under upcoming legislative proposals following the October 2014 European Council conclusions on the EU's 2030 climate and energy framework:

Permanently addressing the surplus

The Market Stability Reserve does not provide a permanent solution to the surplus of EU ETS allowances, which may grow to over 4 billion by 2020. It only temporarily removes allowances and returns them to the market over time. Instead, surplus allowances need to be permanently removed as they weaken future climate targets and undermine an adequate pollution price signal. Legal proposals will have to provide a permanent solution that enables cancellation of surplus allowances.

Strenghtening the linear reduction factor

In the context of ratcheting up EU's 2030 emission target ahead of the Paris summit, the ETS linear reduction factor should be increased in line with an economy-wide target of at least 55% domestic greenhouse gas reductions by 2030 – a target required to ensure the EU's fair contribution to the global effort to prevent dangerous climate change. The European Commission's proposal to increase the linear reduction factor to 2.2% after 2021 is far from sufficient to achieve that purpose.

Revising the approach to protecting industries

When production costs for a business in one country get too high they may move their production to another country. So called „carbon leakage" occurs when the higher costs are due to stricter climate policies in one country and the company therefore moves to a country with weaker climate polices.

The European Commission's own impact assessment shows that there is no evidence for carbon leakage due to the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS). On the contrary, industrial sectors accumulated a surplus of one billion pollution permits, worth well over €5 billion. More than 97% of industry's emissions currently receive free pollution permits. From 2013-2020, industry will receive around 5.5 billion pollution permits for free! As a result, the ETS has rather been a benefit than a cost to many energy intensive industries.

Free allocation led to significant loss of government revenues from auctioning, increased overall costs of climate policy and failed to stimulate investments in emission reductions and innovative technologies. The EU's approach to carbon leakage therefore needs to be significantly altered in order to support clean and competitive industries in Europe whilst at the same time avoiding overcompensation. The polluter pays principle should be respected and will need supplementing with support for additional clean and innovative industry investments. Auctioning of emission allowances instead of free allocations ensures simplicity and transparency and provides revenues that can support industries making the transition to low carbon solutions.

For more information, read our briefing on the lack of evidence for carbon leakage and our presentation on carbon leakage and competitiveness.

Our response to consultation on revision of the EU…

Our response to consultation on revision of the EU ETS Directive

CAN Europe made a submission on the European Commission’s Consultation on the EU-ETS reform post 2020. To date the EU ETS has failed to deliver on its objectives and has not been adapted to respond to the significant macro-economic and technological changes we have seen over the last few years. Only...

Read more

NGOs contest €39bn in free carbon emission allowa…

On 10 December, WWF, CAN Europe, Greenpeace, Carbon Market Watch and Sandbag will file a request for an internal review with the European Commission, contesting the legality of its recent decision to continue granting free carbon emission allowances to industries under the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS). The allowances, for...

Read more

CAN Europe's position on the EU Market Stability R…

CAN Europe's position on the EU Market Stability Reserve proposal

The European Commission's proposal for a Market Stability Reserve published on 22 January 2014 aims to create more price stability in the EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) from 2021 onwards. Under the proposal, EU ETS allowances would automatically be put into the Market Stability Reserve when there is a...

Read more

ETS reform found lacking: EU carbon market proposa…

ETS reform found lacking: EU carbon market proposal published

On January 22 the European Commission published the long-awaited "ETS structural reform" proposal, clarifying that mysterious term which has for a long time described everything from increased 2020 climate targets to permanent cancellation of backloaded allowances. The proposal unveiled by the Commission introduces the concept of a market stability reserve, a...

Read more

Publications

Click below to see the most recent documents available.

EU ETSEU ETS

Position Papers

Click below to see the most recent documents available.

EU ETSEU ETS

  1. CAN Europe's Position on the Market Stability ReserveCAN Europe's Position on the Market Stability Reserve (Details) | Size: 604.01 KB | Added On: Nov 07, 2014
  2. EU ETS at a crossroads - NGO Briefing - January 2013EU ETS at a crossroads - NGO Briefing - January 2013 (Details) | Size: 735.46 KB | Added On: Jan 22, 2013
  3. Q & A on EU ETS Reform (Nov 2012)Q & A on EU ETS Reform (Nov 2012) (Details) | Size: 149.05 KB | Added On: Nov 30, 2012
  4. Bulgarian NGO position on ETS auctioning revenuesBulgarian NGO position on ETS auctioning revenues (Details) | Size: 403.31 KB | Added On: Oct 09, 2012
  5. CAN-Europe Position Paper Best use of auctioning revenues from ETS (July 2012)CAN-Europe Position Paper Best use of auctioning revenues from ETS (July 2012) (Details) | Size: 140.02 KB | Added On: Jul 31, 2012
  6. ČEZ or the Czech Republic who will be the winner? Allowances briefing. (June 2012)ČEZ or the Czech Republic who will be the winner? Allowances briefing. (June 2012) (Details) | Size: Empty | Added On: Jun 19, 2012
  7. Analysis of European Commission options to move beyond 20% GHG reductions (Jan 2012)Analysis of European Commission options to move beyond 20% GHG reductions (Jan 2012) (Details) | Size: 201.65 KB | Added On: Jan 19, 2012
  8. CAN-E submission to public consultation on carbon leakage (12.04.2010)CAN-E submission to public consultation on carbon leakage (12.04.2010) (Details) | Size: 931.44 KB | Added On: Apr 13, 2010
  9. CAN-E Benchmarking EU ETS position paper (Febr. 2010)CAN-E Benchmarking EU ETS position paper (Febr. 2010) (Details) | Size: 482.04 KB | Added On: Feb 16, 2010
  10. CAN-I Position on Carry Over of Kyoto Surplus of Assigned Amount Units (AAUs) (Nov. 2009)CAN-I Position on Carry Over of Kyoto Surplus of Assigned Amount Units (AAUs) (Nov. 2009) (Details) | Size: 174.5 KB | Added On: Nov 02, 2009
  11. EU ETS state of play (Oct. 2009)EU ETS state of play (Oct. 2009) (Details) | Size: 241.76 KB | Added On: Oct 02, 2009
  12. Point Carbon and CAN AAU (Assigned Amount Unit) Report (Oct. 2009)Point Carbon and CAN AAU (Assigned Amount Unit) Report (Oct. 2009) (Details) | Size: 740.12 KB | Added On: Oct 01, 2009
  13. MEP briefing Carbon Leakage (Sept. 2009)MEP briefing Carbon Leakage (Sept. 2009) (Details) | Size: 334.38 KB | Added On: Sep 16, 2009
  14. EU sectoral mechanisms (Sept. 2009)EU sectoral mechanisms (Sept. 2009) (Details) | Size: 341.75 KB | Added On: Sep 13, 2009
  15. Carbon leakage briefing (Sept. 2009)Carbon leakage briefing (Sept. 2009) (Details) | Size: 334.38 KB | Added On: Sep 02, 2009
  16. National Allocation Plans “ an agitator's guide"National Allocation Plans “ an agitator's guide" (Details) | Size: 27.03 KB | Added On: Aug 25, 2009
  17. 2006-Mar_Briefing_paper_Sinks_in_the_EU_ETS_-_FINAL2006-Mar_Briefing_paper_Sinks_in_the_EU_ETS_-_FINAL (Details) | Size: 48 KB | Added On: Aug 25, 2009
  18. CAN E's position on EU dual target (July 2009)CAN E's position on EU dual target (July 2009) (Details) | Size: 187.7 KB | Added On: Jun 29, 2009
  19. Pointcarbon ETS article (May 2009)Pointcarbon ETS article (May 2009) (Details) | Size: 222.15 KB | Added On: May 02, 2009
  20. Presentation INFORSE workshop (Apr. 2009)Presentation INFORSE workshop (Apr. 2009) (Details) | Size: 286.5 KB | Added On: Apr 15, 2009
  21. EU ETS implementation list (Febr. 2009)EU ETS implementation list (Febr. 2009) (Details) | Size: 61.7 KB | Added On: Feb 02, 2009
  22. EU CLIMATE PACKAGE OVERVIEW OF OUTCOME OF 12 DEC. AGREEMENT AND EP VOTE - summary (Jan. 2009)EU CLIMATE PACKAGE OVERVIEW OF OUTCOME OF 12 DEC. AGREEMENT AND EP VOTE - summary (Jan. 2009) (Details) | Size: 350.4 KB | Added On: Jan 02, 2009
  23. Presentation: Global leadership means Domestic Action. An NGO response. EU ETS Conf. (March 2008)Presentation: Global leadership means Domestic Action. An NGO response. EU ETS Conf. (March 2008) (Details) | Size: 623.81 KB | Added On: Mar 16, 2008
  24. 270208 NGO ETS_briefing_“GLOBAL LEADERSHIP MEANS DOMESTIC ACTION”270208 NGO ETS_briefing_“GLOBAL LEADERSHIP MEANS DOMESTIC ACTION” (Details) | Size: 39.5 KB | Added On: Feb 27, 2008
  25. Nov. 2007_Joint NGOs statement on Including aviation in the EU Emissions Trading SchemeNov. 2007_Joint NGOs statement on Including aviation in the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (Details) | Size: 191.85 KB | Added On: Nov 28, 2007
  26. NGO_ECCP_EU_ETS Review_submission (07/2007)NGO_ECCP_EU_ETS Review_submission (07/2007) (Details) | Size: 275.52 KB | Added On: Jul 18, 2007
  27. Qualitative restrictions on the use of CDM/JI credits in the EU ETS (Jun. 2007)Qualitative restrictions on the use of CDM/JI credits in the EU ETS (Jun. 2007) (Details) | Size: 212.43 KB | Added On: Jun 16, 2007
  28. ECCP EU ETS review process: written comments CAN and others (Jun. 2007)ECCP EU ETS review process: written comments CAN and others (Jun. 2007) (Details) | Size: 693.88 KB | Added On: Jun 16, 2007
  29. Allocation methods post 2012: Learning by doing are 2 verbs (May 2007)Allocation methods post 2012: Learning by doing are 2 verbs (May 2007) (Details) | Size: 100.35 KB | Added On: May 16, 2007
  30. Monitoring and permitting: NGO perspective on strengthening the backbone of the EU ETS (Mar. 2007)Monitoring and permitting: NGO perspective on strengthening the backbone of the EU ETS (Mar. 2007) (Details) | Size: 62.85 KB | Added On: Mar 16, 2007
  31. Improving the EU ETS for the climate NGO perspective on the ETS review: SCOPE (Mar. 2007)Improving the EU ETS for the climate NGO perspective on the ETS review: SCOPE (Mar. 2007) (Details) | Size: 1.42 MB | Added On: Mar 16, 2007
  32. WWF-CAN_NAPS_phase II of the EU ETS (February_2007)WWF-CAN_NAPS_phase II of the EU ETS (February_2007) (Details) | Size: 193.31 KB | Added On: Feb 19, 2007
  33. NATIONAL ALLOCATION PLANS 2005-7 Report (05/06)NATIONAL ALLOCATION PLANS 2005-7 Report (05/06) (Details) | Size: 691.56 KB | Added On: May 25, 2006
  34. EEP non-CO2 gases in EU ETS? (Mar. 2006)EEP non-CO2 gases in EU ETS? (Mar. 2006) (Details) | Size: 557.96 KB | Added On: Mar 25, 2006
  35. Briefing Paper: No Sinks in the EU ETS (Mar. 2006)Briefing Paper: No Sinks in the EU ETS (Mar. 2006) (Details) | Size: 48 KB | Added On: Mar 25, 2006
  36. CAN_IEEP_N2O_EUETS_March06CAN_IEEP_N2O_EUETS_March06 (Details) | Size: 223.38 KB | Added On: Mar 24, 2006
  37. CAN-E_position_NAPs_Phase_2_final (june 2005)CAN-E_position_NAPs_Phase_2_final (june 2005) (Details) | Size: 306.28 KB | Added On: Jun 25, 2005
  38. CAN-E presentation on EU ETS review - scope of the EU ETS - no dateCAN-E presentation on EU ETS review - scope of the EU ETS - no date (Details) | Size: 158.81 KB | Added On: Dec 02, 2004
  39. The Durban Declaration on Carbon Trading (Nov. 2004)The Durban Declaration on Carbon Trading (Nov. 2004) (Details) | Size: 115.11 KB | Added On: Nov 25, 2004
  40. Letter on Czech national allocation plan and climate policy (Oct. 2004)Letter on Czech national allocation plan and climate policy (Oct. 2004) (Details) | Size: 38.3 KB | Added On: Oct 25, 2004
  41. Press release: NAPs of the new member states (Oct. 2004)Press release: NAPs of the new member states (Oct. 2004) (Details) | Size: 24.86 KB | Added On: Oct 25, 2004
  42. Press Release:The Linking Directive: Member States must now tighten a weak European deal (Apr. 2004)Press Release:The Linking Directive: Member States must now tighten a weak European deal (Apr. 2004) (Details) | Size: 266.06 KB | Added On: Apr 25, 2004
  43. CAN: Proposed amendment to the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (Febr. 2004)CAN: Proposed amendment to the EU Emissions Trading Scheme (Febr. 2004) (Details) | Size: 39.69 KB | Added On: Feb 25, 2004
  44. CAN letter - Public participation in the national allocation plan process (Nov. 2003)CAN letter - Public participation in the national allocation plan process (Nov. 2003) (Details) | Size: 32.67 KB | Added On: Nov 25, 2003
  45. Emissions Trading Directive a significant step forward, say NGOs (Jul. 2003)Emissions Trading Directive a significant step forward, say NGOs (Jul. 2003) (Details) | Size: 29.49 KB | Added On: Jul 25, 2003
  46. Press release: Dutch Government to buy fake CO2 credits (Mar. 2003)Press release: Dutch Government to buy fake CO2 credits (Mar. 2003) (Details) | Size: 24.7 KB | Added On: Mar 25, 2003
  47. Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Directive: use your vote for an effective system (Oct. 2002)Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Directive: use your vote for an effective system (Oct. 2002) (Details) | Size: 78.95 KB | Added On: Oct 25, 2002
  48. CAN: No credible climate policy without STRONG RULES (Sept. 2002)CAN: No credible climate policy without STRONG RULES (Sept. 2002) (Details) | Size: 82.17 KB | Added On: Sep 25, 2002
  49. German study: Meinungen in der Industrie zur Einfuehrung eines Emissionshandels (Mar. 2002)German study: Meinungen in der Industrie zur Einfuehrung eines Emissionshandels (Mar. 2002) (Details) | Size: 160.74 KB | Added On: Mar 25, 2002
  50. An open letter to EU ministers on the proposal for domestic trading of GHG allowances (Oct. 2002)An open letter to EU ministers on the proposal for domestic trading of GHG allowances (Oct. 2002) (Details) | Size: 116.56 KB | Added On: Feb 25, 2002
  51. Bradley: Brief Critique of the Commission Emissions Trading Paper (Dec. 2001)Bradley: Brief Critique of the Commission Emissions Trading Paper (Dec. 2001) (Details) | Size: 22.17 KB | Added On: Dec 25, 2001
  52. Emission trading in the EU: let’s see some targets! (Dec. 2001)Emission trading in the EU: let’s see some targets! (Dec. 2001) (Details) | Size: 35.82 KB | Added On: Dec 25, 2001
  53. ETCNE - Emissions trading in the EU (Oct. 2000)ETCNE - Emissions trading in the EU (Oct. 2000) (Details) | Size: 35.49 KB | Added On: Oct 25, 2000
  54. (10/2000) EU ETS CAN Europe position paper(10/2000) EU ETS CAN Europe position paper (Details) | Size: 35.49 KB | Added On: Oct 05, 2000

Contact

Anja-Kollmuss-profile-180x180

Anja Kollmuss

Climate policy coordinator

Email: anja/at/caneurope.org

@CANEurope Latest Tweets

CANEurope 19 EU countries face fines, failing to translate #EnergyEfficiency Directive into national law http://t.co/Omp5Dyxfte http://t.co/zc2yzUstGL
16hreplyretweetfavorite
CANEurope RT @KarmenuVella: 8.30pm Saturday 28th March is #EarthHour Use your power - find out more at http://t.co/mkdNSL40A3 @earthhour @EU_ENV http…
CANEurope #EnergyUnion lacks a clear winning strategy - our reaction to the Council conclusions: http://t.co/4ZSJtmy9dO

News

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Prev Next

Member News

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Prev Next

Our Successes

Our Successes

03-06-2013 Our successes

Our Successes

Find out about some of our key achievements in working to prevent dangerous climate change and promote sustainable climate and energy policy in Europe.  July 2014 Dirty 30 report CAN Europe, along...

Read more

Site hosting and support by CrusonWeb